Sunday 18 November 2018

Sinead O’Connor’s Conversion to Islam



Sinead O’Connor’s recent conversion to Islam is likely to have been influenced more by her evidently fragile mental state than any deep understanding of the religion.

However, Westerner’s conversion to Islam does seem to favour females over males by as many as three to one[1], and this is worthy of consideration. 

Western society’s morality is based on intangible rules of behaviour above and beyond legal constraints, and this may produce disquiet for those who prefer a less flexible system.  Islam offers a rules-based morality allowing for – indeed, demanding - moral acquiescence.  This may be more favourable for females because their tendency for empathic solipsism may require a more defined moral code, one with values shared with other women.  As Camille Paglia notes, modern society has displaced women’s role, but not their “emotional and conversational needs that were once fulfilled by other women of multiple generations throughout the agrarian workday in the fields or at home (where the burdens of childcare and eldercare were group shared).”[2] 
For men, with their tendency for systematisation, Islam’s rules may be less a matter of morality and more of authority.  Male conversion may thus be based on different premise to that of females, and may account for the fewer male converts.  Given the reducing importance of masculine roles in the West, it could be speculated that Islam may offer men a more dominant role in society and inclusion in a brotherhood, and thus raise the ratio of male conversion in the future.

It should be noted that this comment represents just a small facet of Islamic conversion in the West, but one which has received little or no coverage.  Other reasons include counter-cultural, empowerment, enforced, idealism, identity, moral, simplicity, competitive advantage, and social.


[1] https://www.cam.ac.uk/research/news/narratives-of-conversion
[2] https://quillette.com/2018/11/10/camille-paglia-its-time-for-a-new-map-of-the-gender-world/

No comments:

Post a Comment

Diary of Defeat

It seems to me that the West [1] is undergoing a transformational change the like of which it has never seen before.   It might compare w...